Filming at the council chamber

Tonight’s (Tuesday’s) full council meeting will be streamed live online. The debate and decisions made available for anyone to view or to catch up on at a time more convenient to their lives.

It’s a service we’ve been running here for several years now following a campaign to be allowed access which was one of several such actions across the UK which resulted in a change in the law to allow anyone to film or record local authority public meetings.

And we’ve been lucky to have volunteer help until recently, with Lorraine Hodgson behind the camera at many of the meetings. The only problem (for us) is – Lorraine enjoyed it so much, she decided to stand as a councillor and has now been elected.

This means we have vacancies for new volunteers to help with the filming – all the equipment and training is provided, all that’s required is the enthusiasm to make local decision-making more visible for the community.

Lorraine explained why she took part: “Helping Richmond Noticeboard film at Richmondshire District Council meetings has been fun and informative. Why not give it a go and help inform local residents of Richmondshire what is going on in their council meetings. It’s easy to do – if I managed to do it anyone can!”

If you would like to find out more, take a look at the coverage tonight via the Facebook page or Twitter @RichmondNYorks, pop into the council meeting after 6.30pm at Mercury House and drop us an email with any questions to RichmondNoticeboardATgmail.com.

The Autumn community noticeboard is here

Closeup calendar page with drawing-pinsThe events noticeboard for this autumn is now open! You can post any community events, meetings, gigs or other what’s on information for this autumn directly by clicking here.

The process is simple to use and completely free of charge and you can use your Twitter or Facebook log-on if you wish.

When you post the details – a poster, text or maybe even a video – it will go through to a holding area for a moderator to check it over to make sure we don’t spam our users. This doesn’t usually take very long.

Start sharing today! Anything happening in or around Richmond in autumn is most welcome and we look forward to seeing your contributions.

Video: How your council tax was decided

It took one hour and 19 minutes and you can see here how the level of council tax we will pay in the next financial year was decided.

A few highlights with approximate timings to scroll to:
25 mins in: Mention of the green bins charge.
30 mins in: Start of the amendment about local business rates.
39 mins in: The lack of car parking charges is mentioned.
41 mins in: Mention of the Tour de France.
44 mins in: A round of applause. (Most unusual!)
54 mins in: “Cheap politicial showboating”.
1 hr and 1 min in: Accusation that a councillor was speaking out because our camera was on.

And then it ends with the vote. Unusually this was named and recorded – something central government expected to be carried out when the authority set its budget.

The vote was firmly (24) in favour and eight against raising the council tax charge by approximately 7.5p per week
in order to retain the council’s reserves and refuse the offer of a grant from the government to facilitate it being frozen.

See the full video here.

* Bonus prize (of no value) to the first viewer to spot the point in the proceedings when a councillor refers to feeling like being ‘sick in a bucket’ ;).

First ever filming at a Richmondshire District Council meeting

photo-108After the request, the lengthy consideration, a workshop and finally that all important ‘yes’ vote we’ve done some filming at the council.

Sadly we were unable to livestream the important Catterick town centre development debate as we’d intended because no wi-fi was made available.

This is unusual – guest wi-fi has been available on every other occasion we’ve attended a meeting but we’re told that it needed to be switched off in readiness for the move the Mercury House.

So the resulting films were something of a plan B and will not be created in this style in the future.

Filmed on a very small hand-held Flip camera (kept about my person for just such emergencies!) one of the the limitations is a lack of separate audio feed so the camera picks up the rather squeaky chairs in the chamber and people rustling papers near to the councillor’s internal microphones.

Those are things which should become much smoother with the professional mic we’ll be using for the live streaming when the council returns in the autumn.

Likewise hopefully the positioning of the camera at either the press bench or the public gallery will be better in the new chamber and not necessitate being directly behind (the, erm, behind) of any public speakers. That was the issue with last night’s filming of both the developer and the traders association which is why we’ve used mostly audio for their submissions in the coverage.

We look forward to getting back to the filming in September and are still on lookout for any more volunteers who’d like to get involved with the filming activity.

We’ll post some further details on the Richmond Noticeboard in due course but if you’re interested in helping out – it could be now and then or on a more regular basis – please do drop me an email to sarah AT n0tice.com.

Council agree to filming of meetings – a personal view of last night’s vote

Image

The full council in session snapped on an iphone – a first?

“Lights, camera, action” tweeted the cabinet minister as we waited in the public gallery of the wood-panelled chamber at Swale House.

In many years of sitting in town halls waiting for particular agenda items to arise it was certainly a first for me to have the secretary of state tweet a message of support to my phone.

But then communities and local government Eric Pickles does have a is a well-publicised passion for matters of transparency in local authority proceedings. (See how things unfolded on Twitter here)

And so we waited for agenda item nine. It seemed an age. There were the usual proceedings of a full council – the  prayers, the wearing of chains, the reporting back of committee papers long since filed into a dusty drawer.

Then the issue was introduced and proposed by deputy council leader Mick Griffiths – who made the point that this change in constitution was not just something to accommodate me, but would have the effect of allowing anyone, including councillors themselves, to participate in meetings using digital tools.

As he spoke, little did we know at that point that, in a little piece of inspired theatre saved for dramatic effect later on, the councillor was actually filming some of what was being said on his laptop in the chamber.

This is a non-political issue and a free vote. Whilst the approach from an individual has been the catalyst for this, it is the broad approach we need to consider.

The modern world has moved on. This sort of technology appeals more to younger people and how often have we said we should engage with younger people.

There was even a little competition to second the proposal. Richmond councillor Linda Curran become the official seconder although admitting she felt “a little nervous” about being filmed while Leyburn councillor Fleur Butler urged councillors not to make themselves look foolish by behaving like the Welsh council which had a member of the public arrested for filming.

Of course there were a few nay-sayers – three people voted against in the final count. Swaledale councillor Malcolm Gardner was one of them. His objection being that, in his view, rules were all too often flouted on the internet and “he had no faith in that sort of media whatsoever.”

But the forthright views of many including Middleton Tyas councillor Jill McMullon  won out.

We are here to represent people so it’s only right they can see what we are doing. We have to move with the times so let’s do it for heaven’s sake.

25 members voted for a change in the constitution.

So what happens next?

The council has a break in the meeting cycle during August but there is a planning meeting next week where the issue of Catterick Garrison’s town centre is being discussed. It would seem an ideal opportunity to open that debate up to a wider audience and also test out equipment etc. ahead of the council coming back in the autumn.

We’ll start putting the wheels in motion on that today and keep you posted here.

Plus we’ll be on the lookout for any more volunteers who’d like to get involved with the filming activity. We’ll post some further details on the Richmond Noticeboard in due course but if you’re interested in helping out – it could be now and then or on a more regular basis – please do drop me an email to sarah AT n0tice.com.

Update at 4.40pm: The specialist public policy website Information Daily has featured the Richmondshire case today.

Council will decide on filming request on Tuesday

no_filmingWe finally have our day for the council filming decision and it’s next Tuesday.

The full council will consider the request we made back in March to be able to film some local council meetings so you can more easily see the decisions being made at a time and place to suit you.

It’s been quite a journey since that first request to the council leaders during which the Communities and Local Government minister Eric Pickles issued new guidelines giving many members the public the right to film public meetings.

Sadly that right doesn’t extend to Richmondshire as the council doesn’t operate on a cabinet structure and so it will be down the elected councillors to decide whether they will change their rules and go with the spirit of the guidelines rather than continue as they currently do without that opportunity for better scrutiny by local residents.

Which way will it go? Too difficult to call I’m afraid – we have already had written support from the council leader John Blackie, deputy Mick Griffiths and independent ward councillor Stuart Parsons.

At the presentation last month, the mood seemed generally supportive but only a handful of councillors turned out to find out more about the issue so it’s genuinely difficult to judge the wider mood.

In the report prepared by Michael Dowson, he notes that “the existing rule has been in place for some time and does not address changes in technology and social media culture which allow for simultaneous recording and broadcast via the internet.”

There is no recommendation beyond “that members confirm whether they wish to allow the filming and broadcast of all meetings open to the public” but in the accompanying appendix he outlines a suggested protocol which states.

The Council supports the principle of transparency and encourages filming, recording and taking photographs at its meetings that are open to the public. It also welcomes the use of social networking websites (such as Twitter and Facebook) and micro-blogging to communicate with people about what is happening, as it happens.

Read the full agenda paper below and if you like to join us in the public gallery of the council chamber at Swale House next week (6.30pm) as we wait with bated breath to hear the outcome, it would be great to see you.

Council responds to William Hague’s filming enquiry

20130713-211048.jpg
William Hague MP has been appraised of the council’s current thinking about our request to film some public meetings in order that people in the town can more easily follow the decisions being taken by elected members.

In a letter dated 11 July, the council’s corporate director Callum McKeon updated him on our recent presentation to councillors and said a meeting where a vote will be taken is still being organised.

The Deputy Leader of the Council has asked for a report to be taken to a full Council meeting so the subject can be discussed further and in greater detail. Ms Hartley will be able to put her views forward at that meeting and it is hoped that a vote can be taken on the subject and a decision made. It is hoped that a report will be able to be brought to the July Council meeting but if this is not possible then the matter will be considered in October.

So we continue to wait for the invite…………

This type of conversation is going on all around the country at the moment with some council’s reacting with some hostility to requests from people wanting to film while others, such as Bradford City, have taken quick votes to allow it straight away before the longer processes of changing constitutions are undertaken.

I’m mapping the responses as they come to light here.

Presentation to Richmondshire councillors discussing the filming of meetings

The slideshow here was presented to Richmondshire councillors attending a workshop to learn more about the Richmond Noticeboard and ask questions about our proposal to film some council meetings.

A handful of councillors attended plus officials for the hour-long session. Questions ranged from questions about ownership of any filmed material (to be issued under a Creative Commons licence) to issues about bandwidth in locations outside of the town.

The decision will be taken at a meeting in the near future – if you have any questions you’d like answered ahead of that, please do feel free to submit them via the comments below.

It seems that Hambleton council were also considering this issue today.Note:the report from the Northern Echo linked to contains some inaccuracies which I’ve corrected in the comments underneath the story.

Still hoops to jump through in fight to film our elected councillors

Our early jubilation at seemingly being granted the right to film council meetings has been somewhat dampened today.

In response to an email from Sarah, Richmondshire Council questioned whether last week’s issuing of new rules from the Department for Communities and Local Government applied to them.

After contacting the department for clarification it seems they do not automatically apply because Richmondshire doesn’t operate a cabinet structure for decision making – more here on that.

They can of course change their current position to demonstrate they are willing to be more open by allowing filming and we will be pressing for that to happen when we meet with councillors next week.

We will continue to update this blog as matters progress.

Local government office gives us new rights to film

While Richmondshire Council mull over the possibility of people filming their council meetings, the Local Government Secretary Eric Pickles has moved to provide bloggers and journalists with the right to film any of their proceedings held in public.

His office today produced a new guide for local people explaining how they can attend and report their local council meetings – and it explicitly states that Councils should allow the public to film meetings.

The new how-to guide (in full below) gives practical information for the public to attend meetings of a council’s executive and how to obtain council documents.

I’ve blogged more about the guide here and this morning sent a link about the changes over to the council leader, deputy leader, my ward councillor and some of the officers who have been involved in the discussions. Whether the workshop for members will now go-ahead given the changed circumstances is also unclear – while it seems unneccessary now, I’m happy to take the opportunity to answer any questions from members on the issue.

I await their response and will update the blog with more as it progresses.